Scuttlebutt NY Guard CERFP Story 2 2

Case-by-Case Readiness: Scuttlebutt Explores Tailored Standards for State Defense Forces

In this Scuttlebutt clip, host Jean Marciniak, Director of The State Guard & Defense Force Council, and cohost Major (GA – Retired) Beverly Shepard explore whether future National Standards for State Defense Forces should be applied broadly across all states or tailored on a case-by-case basis. They highlight how individuals in their 60s and 70s can often outperform younger applicants in fitness, bring decades of leadership experience, and offer critical emergency-response skills—especially in areas like IT, logistics, and organizational management that strongly support National Guard missions. The discussion also examines objections raised by some SDF Commanders who prefer establishing their own state-specific standards rather than adopting a unified national model. They further address the Louisiana State Guard’s decision to modify its requirements by allowing those who do not meet height-and-weight standards to serve in blue polos and khaki pants—a well-intentioned adaptation that, if can become a slippery slope for State Defense Forces civilianizing. 

Listen to the full podcast -> Click Here

Subscribe to Commanders Briefing Clips via your Podcast app:

iPhone: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/scuttlebutt-clips/id1819356645

Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/6B4orLhTIEjSqvIe7FLGoP

The Scuttlebutt Podcast are only available to our Patreon members – Corporal $5 Tier and above. We provide this to them as a thank you for keeping StateDefenseForce.com online and running. Through their funding we can pay authors to develop these historical pieces as well as fund our new lobbying program that furthers the State Defense Force cause nationwide.

Tags: No tags

Comments are closed.